Vibe Check: How to Build a Roster Like You’d Make a Mixtape

  • I’ve been thinking a lot about how most analysts spit out rankings (some based on math, some based on lord knows what), and they come up with different strategies that they think will best suit them (and you) in order to win, which is the main point of this activity, hobby, or obsession (I guess everybody’s take on fantasy hoops is different). Some pros like to heavily punt categories; others like to have a more balanced approach. Some very strongly advocate for certain must-have players, while others very much advise not to reach and lose value, and others are not at all fazed by the unethical or illegal actions of certain players and will roster them without thinking twice.

    For me, it is very important for each and every one of my teams to have a certain vibe. Some of this is dependent upon the format, some of it is dependent upon whether I’m entering into an already-established league or joining one that’s starting from scratch. Sometimes, it takes shape straightaway on draft night; other times, it takes a few weeks of trades and waiver wire action to get things just right. But there are most definitely certain guys I often to always target, because their vibes are simply impeccable (in my opinion), and I’m willing to draft them over more vanilla dudes who might have “a better ranking.” There are also some dudes that I will never ever roster under any circumstance.

    I’d like to just throw this out there as a concept for some of you to try. Don’t do it in every league, like I do, because you might end up hating this approach. But maybe give it a shot in a lower-stakes league — you know, like a free one or one you play in with friends and/or family. See what happens. Maybe you come to the same conclusion that I have, which is that winning is, of course, the main objective, but it’s far more fun to win when you actually like rooting for the players on your roster than it is when they kind of make you cringe.

    I decided it might be an enjoyable exercise for me (and for you) if I constructed ten teams in the mold of mixtapes, inspired by specific genres. Since the standard go-to number of roster spots, for whatever reason, tends to be 13, I will select 13 players per team. I will not limit myself to bullshit position designations, since the NBA doesn’t. If you want to have a team that is mostly composed of wings, you can — just ask the new-look Brooklyn Nets.

    Disclaimer: I chose not to go outside the realm of actual fantasy-relevant players; although, there are plenty of players still in the league that could have made it onto some of these mixtapes.

    Okay, here we go!

    Adult Contemporary

    This group of grandparent-approved guys were the ones who told on you for telling naughty jokes on the playground, they were always the first ones to raise their hands to answer any question in any class from sixth grade on, and they think Stephen A. Smith has a point when he tells professional athletes to “stay off the weeeeeeed.” Many of them seem like genuinely well-intentioned dudes, but many they often just can’t help themselves from doing corny things: Steph Curry is a NIMBY bro with a wannabe influencer wife, LeBron only reads the first page of books and retroactively suggests that he had bizarre premonitions, Buddy Hield tweets, “Thank God For Life, Health and Strength” every single day, Chris Paul bitches and moans every chance he can get, and D’Angelo Russell and Karl-Anthony Towns are the world’s worst (or best, depending on your perspective) podcast guests ever. If you drink milk as an adult, you might not think there is anything weird about any of this behavior.

    Deandre Ayton

    Steph Curry

    Anthony Davis

    Spencer Dinwiddie

    Tobias Harris

    Buddy Hield

    Al Horford

    LeBron James

    Khris Middleton

    Chris Paul

    Julius Randle

    D’Angelo Russell

    Karl-Anthony Towns

    Afrobeat

    The following players all have a specific, syncopated rhythm to their games — they can go from being a bit herky-jerky to smooth, like a Parliament cigarette. They are each consistent in their ways, often chugging along and then catching fire at any moment. They can dazzle you with handles or footwork or pull up from almost anywhere on the court and catch you off guard with some freeform flair or with surprisingly straightforward get-it-done work ethic.

    Bradley Beal

    Mikal Bridges

    Kevin Durant

    Anthony Edwards

    Joel Embiid

    Paul George

    Brandon Ingram

    Kyrie Irving

    Kawhi Leonard

    Damian Lillard

    Donovan Mitchell

    Jamal Murray

    Jayson Tatum

    Black Metal/Death Metal

    These dudes are the grinders, the punishers, the unstoppables. They will coming charging at you like a lovelorn bull. They’ll set fire to your well-conceived plans. They don’t give a shit about your feelings. They are on-court atheists, nihilistic about “the fundamentals.” They’ll tell your dad to STFU.

    Steven Adams

    Giannis Antetokounmpo

    Clint Capela

    Jalen Duren

    Markelle Fultz

    Aaron Gordon

    Scoot Henderson

    Jakob Poeltl

    Bobby Portis

    Mitchell Robinson

    Jonas Valančiūnas

    Robert Williams III

    Zion Williamson

    Classic Rock

    If you’re a player with bad facial hair, you’re classic rock. If you’ve ever chewed tobacco, you’re classic rock. If you’ve ever owned a jean jacket, you’re classic rock. If you still use Facebook, you’re classic rock. If you don’t really turn the ball over, you’re classic rock. If when you’re at the doctor’s office, you check off “White/European,” you’re probably classic rock.

    Bojan Bogdanovic

    Malcolm Brogdon

    Zach Collins

    Rudy Gobert

    Tyus Jones

    Walker Kessler

    Brook Lopez

    Jusuf Nurkic

    Kelly Olynyk

    Michael Porter Jr.

    Kristaps Porziņģis

    Nikola Vucevic

    Franz Wagner

    EDM/House

    These are the fellas who don’t talk too much talk. They’ve got a chill swagger to them. They’re pretty happy-go-lucky. They mostly just want to make fun plays happen and win ball games. Some of them can be a bit rough around the edges, but with enough repetition, they tend to grow on you.

    Desmond Bane

    Scottie Barnes

    DeMar DeRozan

    De’Aaron Fox

    Darius Garland

    Jerami Grant

    Cameron Johnson

    Kyle Kuzma

    Tyrese Maxey

    Trey Murphy III

    Jordan Poole

    Pascal Siakam

    Anfernee Simons

    Free Jazz

    Free jazz is about intuition and inventiveness. These hoopers have an innate feel for the game. They see things that other players do not; they can make something out of nothing. They often make you question what you know or knew about basketball. There’s a lot of “how he do that” to their style of play. It’s a certain type of poetry that often is hard to put your finger on…

    Jalen Brunson

    Cade Cunningham

    Luka Dončić

    Josh Giddey

    Shai Gilgeous-Alexander

    Tyrese Haliburton

    Nikola Jokic

    Austin Reaves

    Domantas Sabonis

    Alperen Şengün

    Amen Thompson

    Ausar Thompson

    Jalen Williams

    Hardcore/Punk

    Anarchy in the NBA! If you want grit, look no further. Diving on the deck, swatting shots from behind, suffocating players with intense, frenetic energy — these players give it their all, every second that they’re out there. When basketball minds mention a player’s motor, they’re usually talking about how he’s lacking. None of these homies are lacking in motor, that’s for sure. They play fast, they play hard, they play loud.

    Jimmy Butler

    Alex Caruso

    Nicolas Claxton

    Tari Eason

    Draymond Green

    Jrue Holiday

    Herb Jones

    Dejounte Murray

    Marcus Smart

    Jabari Smith Jr.

    Matisse Thybulle

    Fred VanVleet

    Devin Vassell

    Hip-Hop/Rap

    Hip-hop/rap — clearly, the coolest genre; all of these guys are either cool or want to be cool. What is cool, or how cool, is often in the eye of the beholder. I’m not saying all of these guys are cool; you decide if they are and how much and how so.

    LaMelo Ball

    John Collins

    Devin Booker

    Jaylen Brown

    Jordan Clarkson

    James Harden

    Tyler Herro

    Jaren Jackson Jr.

    Zach LaVine

    Ja Morant

    Terry Rozier

    Russell Westbrook

    Trae Young

    IDM

    This is not a style of basketball people who were born before, like, 1975 probably understand very well. None of these guys fit into any boxes you can get at Home Depot. Guards who rebound, forwards with handles, centers with court vision. Long scarves, bleached hair, slow-motion shooting mechanics. Good luck trying to explain how these guys play to your uncle.

    Bam Adebayo

    Kyle Anderson

    O.G. Anunoby

    Bruce Brown

    Josh Hart

    Chet Holmgren

    Jaden McDaniels

    De’Anthony Melton

    Onyeka Okongwu

    Shaedon Sharpe

    Jeremy Sochan

    Gary Trent Jr.

    Victor Wembanyama

    Yacht Rock

    Very talented men who get the job done.

    Jarrett Allen

    Paolo Banchero

    Wendell Carter Jr.

    Mike Conley

    Kevin Huerter

    Lauri Markkanen

    CJ McCollum

    Evan Mobley

    Keegan Murray

    Klay Thompson

    Myles Turner

    Derrick White

    Andrew Wiggins

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x